Light IGA: Myths & Facts about Modern Identity Governance & Administration

Light IGA solutions promise a quick & easy path to Identity Governance & Administration, positioning themselves as quick to deploy and easy to use compared to “heavy” Legacy IGA tools. In this article, we’ll examine whether these claims of fast implementation and lower workloads are too good to be true and look at the real differences between Light IGA and conventional solutions. It’s time to separate fact from fiction.

What Is Light IGA?

The term Light IGA describes solutions for Identity Governance & Administration that can be deployed faster and require less effort to manage and operate than traditional IGA platforms. Lightweight solutions achieve this by streamlining and simplifying the setup process, as well as focusing on out-of-the-box integrations. This allows Light IGA to offer a comprehensive governance toolset at a much lower cost than Legacy IGA solutions, which a require long and expensive setup.

Characteristics of Light IGA solutions:

  • Streamlined setup

  • User-friendly interface

  • Minimal overhead

  • Out-of-the-box support for apps

  • No-code integration & workflows

  • Simplified, comprehensive governance

Infographic showing the advantages of Light IGA solutions like no-code configuration and out-of-the-box integrations.
Light IGA Infographic

Light IGA vs. Legacy IGA

Light IGA is often put up against traditional solutions in the Identity Governance space. There are different ways to phrase this comparison โ€“ light vs. heavy or modern vs. legacy โ€“ but the main difference being asserted remains the same: Light IGA solutions are faster and easier than conventional governance platforms.

To see whether there is anything to this claim, let’s first look at Legacy IGA. There’s no denying that traditional IGA solutions offer a wide range of features. On paper, these legacy platforms can address any use case you throw at them. But in practice, there’s a big problem that limits the effective usage of Legacy IGA: These tools were designed to serve the needs of huge enterprises.

Legacy IGA is built to be infinitely tweakable and customizable โ€“ which is necessary to accommodate the many internal inconsistencies in enterprise-scale environments: Office A uses completely different apps and processes than Office B. Office C was acquired in a merger and never fully integrated with our network and then there’s a satellite office in another country that has to comply with different regulations, and so on and so on.

Glass skyscraper in a business district.
Unless your headquarter looks like this, you probably don’t need an enterprise IGA solution. Adobe Stock, (c) JFL Photography

But this degree of flexibility has a price: Legacy IGA requires heavy customization to become operational. Solutions like these often take years to roll out and many deployments end up unfinished, in distress or worse.

By focusing on speed and out-of-the-box support, Light IGA is able to reduce deployment time without compromising on functionality. A modern IGA platform can be fully operational in just a few weeks.

In summary: Just because something is more flexible does not make it the better option. The heavy customization required by Legacy IGA makes these tools slow and costly to roll out, while leaving you with significant tech debt. By contrast, Light IGA is designed for quick deployment and easy operation, saving time and minimizing operational overhead.

Identity Providers vs. Dedicated IGA Platforms

While the term Light IGA emerged to describe a new breed of modern, full-scale IGA solutions that offer simplified deployment and operations, it is sometimes used to refer to the built-in governance tools packaged with Identity Providers or other security solutions.

For example: Platforms like Okta or Entra ID, which are primarily used for their authentication, single sign-on and directory services, have started to incorporate some governance features into their products, such as basic support for user lifecycles or self-service requests.

The problem with these offerings is that IGA is not the focus of the product, which means they only offer a limited, pared-down set of features. The governance toolset packaged with Identity Providers is simply not on-par with a dedicated IGA solution.

These built-in IGA tools do not give you fine-grained control over entitlements. Instead of comprehensive governance and in-depth visibility, IdPs only allow you to manage group-based permissions, and only for apps that can be connected to that Identity Provider. Resources that cannot be managed through the IdP fall through the cracks. Not to mention various functional limitations like missing support for complex workflows or automations.

In summary: While Identity Providers are starting to offer some governance features under the Light IGA banner, these cut-down toolsets cannot be compared to a dedicated IGA solution. Light IGA should reduce complexity, not capability! Modern IGA platforms like tenfold combine quick & easy deployment with comprehensive governance.

Which Kind of IGA is Right For Me?

The question of what kind of IGA solution you should use depends on many factors, including the size, structure and specific needs of your organization. Identity Governance and Administration is only one area in the larger field of Identity & Access Management, so it’s important to think about which challenges you are trying to solve and what type of solution is best suited to that need.

  • Built-in IGA: The governance tools packaged with cloud or identity providers are can ease user administration for existing customers, but are no replacement for a dedicated IGA solution. Their limited usability can make them an option for organizations with low governance workloads and no compliance/security challenges.

  • Legacy IGA: Conventional, heavy IGA solutions are built for well resourced organizations that can shoulder the budget and personnel strain of a multi-year setup phase, as well as ongoing operations and maintenance. Although powerful, Legacy IGA solutions can only be used effectively in large-scale enterprise environments.

  • Light, Modern IGA: Light IGA offers full-featured, comprehensive governance without the long setup and heavy customization required by legacy platforms. This makes Light IGA the right choice for most organizations, especially small to mid-sized businesses that need a cost-effective way to streamline governance, compliance and identity security.

Light IGA: Myth vs. Fact

1

Myth #1: Light IGA Has a Limited Set of Features

The view of Light IGA as a pared-down version of full IGA platform that only includes some of the necessary features for effective governance is likely rooted in the use of the term to describe the built-in IGA capabilities of Identity Providers and other products.

It’s true that platforms which offer IGA on the side are no replacement for a dedicated IGA solution. But this not the only form of Light IGA! There are full-featured solutions like tenfold that combine the quick and easy deployment of Light IGA with a comprehensive governance toolset.

tenfold Features:

  • Role-based Access Control

  • Lifecycle Automation

  • In-depth Reporting

  • User Access Reviews

  • End User Self-Service

  • Customizable Workflows

  • Cloud & On-Prem Governance

  • No-Code Integration

Verdict: Not true! However, it’s important to choose a mature, dedicated IGA solution instead of relying on the built-in tools of Identity Providers or other security solutions.

2

Myth #2: Light IGA Does Not Support Complex Processes

Some organizations worry that because Light IGA aims to simplify Identity & Access Governance, that means it can only handle simple tasks. This concern is stoked by legacy solutions, who like to argue that their complicated tools are necessary to deal with complex workflows.

This is not true. Light IGA solutions are designed to cover all your governance needs. From complex workflows to intricate rulesets and tiered, multi-stage approval processes, Light IGA can handle any task you throw at it. There are very few, hyper-specific scenarios that only legacy platforms can deal with โ€“ which are not relevant for 99.99% of organizations!

So should you buy a slower, more complex solution because you are worried about an entirely hypothetical scenario? Obviously not! That would be like buying a semitruck for daily driving, just in case you suddenly need to move a shipping container from A to B.

Verdict: Not true! While Light IGA focuses on a streamlined and user-friendly interface, that does not mean it lacks the power to take on complex tasks and intricate workflows.

3

Myth #3: Light IGA Only Covers Group-Based Entitlements

When it comes to governing access, the devil is in the details. To protect sensitive data and ensure compliance, you need fine-grained control over IT privileges. A solution that can only manage group-based permissions and show you which apps a user can access is not enough! What about permission roles within applications? What about object-level permissions on file servers, file shares or cloud documents?

The good news is: There are dedicated governance solutions under the Light IGA umbrella that go beyond group-based entitlements to give you in-depth visibility and control. For example, tenfold offers both IGA and a comprehensive toolset for data access governance, giving you complete control over user access.

Verdict: Not true! Though capabilities vary from solution to solution, there are plenty of Light IGA platforms like tenfold that go beyond surface-level permissions.

White paper

Access Governance Best Practices for Microsoft Environments

Everything you need to know about implementing access control best practices in Active Directory, from implementation tips to common mistakes.

4

Myth #4: Light IGA Does Not Offer Out-of-the-Box Integrations

This myth is especially harmful because in reality, the opposite is true! Legacy IGA providers like to make bold claims about their rich and deep integrations, but the truth is that these require heavy customization before they are ready to use. Typically, legacy solutions offer an API or connector, but rely on customers and consultants to code how these different apps should interact.

By contrast, Light IGA solutions focus on fully functional out-of-the-box integration, meaning that that these platforms offer ready-to-use plugins that come with templates for essential workflows, allowing you to start automating governance tasks right away. That means no long and complex setup, just activate a plugin, tweak a few settings and you’re good to go!

Verdict: Not true! Light IGA specializes in quick and easy deployment thanks to its out-of-the-box integrations that come with templates and ready-to-use workflows.

5

Fact: Light IGA Is the Best Fit For Most Organizations

Rising threats and complex, hybrid environments make IGA a growing need for organizations of all sizes. But existing legacy solutions are a poor fit for most organizations due to their high cost, long setup and huge workload.

This excessive burden is exactly what drove the development of smart, modern Light IGA solutions like tenfold. By offering the same comprehensive governance toolset with less effort and a much faster deployment, Light IGA allows orgs with smaller budgets, smaller IT teams and smaller user bases to tackle governance challenges with a quick, convenient and cost-effective solution.

Verdict: True! With the exception of very few enterprise-level orgs, most are better served by modern IGA solutions that offer quick deployment and streamlined operations than traditional, heavyweight IGA platforms that require a long setup and heavy maintenance.

tenfold: Light, Modern & Comprehensive IGA

Are you looking for a way to simplify the administration of user accounts and IT privileges? tenfold, our revolutionary No-Code IAM solution, is the fastest and most convenient way to automate governance tasks from user lifecycles to access audits and in-depth reporting.

But you don’t have to take our word for it! Book a personal demo to see tenfold in action and speak to a qualified tech ready to answer any questions you might have about integrating tenfold with your stack. Or sign up for a free 30-day trial, to explore our IGA solution yourself. This trial offer includes four hours of free consulting to set up our platform and unlimited tech support.

If you need modern, lightweight IGA platform to automate governance and streamline IT operations, then look no further than tenfold. Contact us today to learn more.

Govern Identities & Data Access With Ease: Learn How tenfold Can Help

About the Author: Joe Kรถller

Joe Kรถller is tenfoldโ€™s Content Manager and responsible for the IAM Blog, where he dives deep into topics like compliance, cybersecurity and digital identities. From security regulations to IT best practices, his goal is to make challenging subjects approachable for the average reader. Before joining tenfold, Joe covered games and digital media for many years.